Sunday, February 26, 2006

FILMS FIESTA: Proof (3) : Proof is for nothing


When she opened the notebook and began to read, he, her father stood still, motionless, waiting a verdict upon his intelligence to come to an end.

She announced it, something she detested to do while he listened, something he knew despite he preferred to get it unnoticed.

The Proof.

Yes I do. I do like this film with all my heart.

It could be mean to perceive one and another, and the next to come, which we are not sure, or out of our knowledge, even brain stops thinking. “Proof” intends to invite us to see our identity, the ultimate layer of ourselves, the ‘self’ we have been playing for all the growing-ups; we are so eager to get things proven, are we not?

Our identity is checked before our departure in airports, illness is consulted according to the jotted scheduled and the post-diagnosis, could possibly we ever sense with a special remark, could someone there to tell us when we should and should not do this or that?

Dates, times, venues, objectives are all recorded. All we need is some proofs. We need guidance in this world because we know nothing, are we not? So it’s basically logically to get all things labeled and scheduled as it is non-sensical to see things are left completely empty ,stagnant, dead... yes, that’s why people hate to see the death.

Because, Death is the only proof to prove emptiness overtakes anything.

Probably “Proof” as it seems, is taken as a medium for mathematicians to get all proofs unsolved. In fact it is not.

Proofs come after nothing. Only those who wanted to know would seek for proofs and there are writings, dates and other important things to get seeker’s curiosity fulfilled.

Claire, her sister is good at finding evidence; Robert, her father is a genius in finding mathematician’s proofs; Hal, Robert’s prized student, is good enough to find his teacher’s evidence.

Only Catherine, the one the role who is presumed as ‘abnormal’ or ‘mentally ill’ among her circle, recognize that proof is only a proof, and it proves nothing.

Likewise, it is rather ironical to know our most demanding seek-after careers, ranging from lawyers, doctors, teachers, engineers, journalists, corporate to labourers and maidens. People are rushing to adore the proofs in the past and generate proofs in the present. The governors, the people even marriage ought to need at least a paper to show a thing ‘exists’. (Excluding the thought to have at least some insurance policies to assure one’s reliability and trust-worthiness to privilege a marriage)

Good questions arise: What will we become if we find our genius and specialty has gone one day? Losing our identity? People can’t recognize us? Getting downwards after 23? Females are not so prominent in the world of mathematics? Serious academic learners can’t do music? Insane is defined an abnormal act or a proof of unconstructive and disorder mentally-ill behavioural self-supportive communication system?  

What a world! If I were Catherine, to tell you the truth, I will not accept Hal as shown in the last scene. He is just too used to the world of proofs and logic. He lost to the deep-rooted desire to ‘can-be-seen’ and judgment is always derailed and shakable. Not an excuse to his reimbursement after a week even after the next second, no matter how true the proof he was trying to unveil, it is just too late.

He is no other than among the blind that we know, because we all are.


Top 10 The Best Films (DVD)
Top 10 The Best Films (Over all)
The Best Film
The Best Actress

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home